← All articles
Reputation· 4 min read

How to respond to a bad review, with scripts for tradies

You finish a long day, check your phone, and there it is: one star and a paragraph about how you ruined someone's weekend. Your first instinct is to fire back. Don't. The reply you write isn't really for the person who left the review. It's for every customer who reads it after them.

26%
of Australians who post online reviews said a business getting back to them after a bad review would change their opinion of it, and another 49% said maybe, according to the Yellow Social Media Report 2020.

Why the reply matters more than the review

That Yellow figure comes from 840 Australians who post reviews. 26% said a reply would change their opinion, and another 49% said maybe. Only 25% said a reply wouldn't change their opinion.

The stakes are real. BrightLocal's Local Consumer Review Survey 2026 found 77% of US consumers say negative reviews make them less likely to choose a business. But readers don't just see the complaint. They see how you handled it.

And a bad review isn't always a disaster. PowerReviews research, cited in a report from Northwestern University's Spiegel research team, found 82% of shoppers specifically seek out negative reviews. People go looking for the worst thing anyone has said about you, to see if they can live with it. A calm, fair reply is often what tips them your way.

Before you type anything

  1. 1Wait until you've cooled off. A few hours, or the next morning. Never reply from the ute in a temper.
  2. 2Check the job. Find the quote, the invoice, any texts or photos. Work out what actually happened.
  3. 3Decide what's fair. Was something your fault, even partly? Own that part.
  4. 4Work out what you can offer: a return visit, a call, a refund on part of the job, or simply an explanation.
  5. 5Keep private details out. No addresses, no phone numbers, nothing about their home or their money beyond what they've said.

Scripts for the bad reviews tradies get most

Change the details so it sounds like you. BrightLocal found generic or templated replies put off 50% of US consumers, who may see them as a sign of poor customer care.

"The bill was way more than the quote"

Thanks for letting us know, Dave. Once we opened the wall it turned out the old pipe had corroded further along than we could see, which added time and parts. I rang you before going ahead, but I can see it still came as a shock, and I should have put it in writing. I've given you a call to go through the invoice line by line.

"They turned up late" or "they didn't turn up"

You're right, and I'm sorry. An earlier job ran over and we didn't let you know early enough. That's not good enough. We've changed how we handle running late so customers get a text as soon as we know. I'd like to make it up to you, so please give me a ring.

"The work wasn't finished properly"

Thanks for raising this, Priya. If something isn't right, we'll come back and fix it at no charge. I've sent you a message to book a time this week.

When you can't find them in your records

Sorry to hear about this. I can't find a job under this name in our records, so I'm not sure we've worked together. If we have, please call the office so we can look into it straight away.

What not to do

  • Don't argue the details in public. Give the short version and take the rest offline.
  • Don't blame the customer, even if they're partly at fault. Readers side with the customer by default.
  • Don't offer a refund or discount on the condition they delete or change the review.
  • Don't get mates or staff to post glowing reviews to bury it. That can breach the Australian Consumer Law.
  • Don't ignore it. Silence reads as either not caring or not being able to answer.

When a review should come down

Some reviews aren't genuine: a competitor, someone who was never a customer, or an obvious spam attack. The ACCC's guidance is that if a business thinks a platform has published a false or misleading review about it, it should contact the platform and ask for the review to be removed, or respond to the review to correct the public record.

What you can't do is remove or hide genuine negative reviews just because you don't like them. The ACCC is clear that suppressing genuine negative reviews can mislead consumers. There's more on where the line sits in fake reviews and the ACCC.

You're not alone in hating this part

If bad reviews keep you up at night, you're in good company. The Yellow Social Media Report 2020 found 22% of Australian small and medium businesses say they're concerned about receiving negative reviews or ratings online. It's one of the most common frustrations owners mention.

The best long-term defence is plenty of recent, genuine reviews, so one bad one is a blip rather than the headline. See why you should reply to your good reviews too for the habit that builds that buffer.

Heading off the next one

Most bad reviews for tradies come back to a few causes: surprise costs, no-shows and poor communication. Agentize helps with those, though it doesn't reply to or manage reviews. Quotes are itemised and priced only from your own rate card, with anything unpriced flagged rather than guessed. Customers get a day-before reminder, and when they text, the message lands in the app with a reply drafted for you to check and send. Fewer surprises means fewer one-star paragraphs.

When one does land, take a breath, check the facts, own your part and offer to fix it. Done well, a bad review can show the next customer exactly how you treat people when things go wrong.

KEEP READING

LET THE CREW DO THE ADMIN.

Agentize quotes your jobs, sends the invoices and chases the cash, in your name, from your own rates. Your first 8 quotes free. 7 days. No card.

Start free trial See how the Agentize crew works