Most trade jobs go fine. Nobody writes to the regulator about a tap that was fixed on time. But the jobs that do go wrong shape how every customer feels about the next tradie they hire, so it pays to know where things break down.
What the national consumer survey shows
The Australian Consumer Survey is run for Australia's consumer regulators. The 2023 edition, carried out by Kantar Public, surveyed 5,452 consumers about problems with things they had bought. Building, renovations, repairs and home maintenance came in at 11%, a big drop from 17% in 2016.
That fall is good news for the industry. Problems are less common than they were. But the next numbers show why the ones that remain hit customers hard.
These problems are expensive and hard to fix
When a consumer's most recent problem was in this category, the average purchase price behind it was $10,874. That's far more than most everyday purchases that go wrong. And building, renovation, repair and maintenance problems were the least likely of any category to be resolved to the customer's satisfaction.
Only 27% of those problems were resolved to the customer's satisfaction, and 41% were unresolved or unlikely to be resolved. For the customer, that's a lot of money and a lot of stress with no clean ending. No wonder trust is the first thing they look for next time.
What regulators are seeing in Queensland
State building regulators handle the formal complaints. In Queensland, the QBCC's 2024-25 annual report recorded 5,771 defective building work complaints, down from 6,115 the year before. Each one is a homeowner who felt the work wasn't up to standard and went to the regulator about it.
Those complaints cover building work broadly, not every trade, but they're a reminder that defects and disputes are a real, ongoing part of the industry. For a customer, lodging a formal complaint is usually the last step after calls and messages have gone nowhere, so behind each one there's often a long stretch of frustration first.
Where jobs actually go wrong
Not every bad job is about poor workmanship. A 2024 Houzz survey of homeowners (not specific to Australia) found 55% faced some kind of challenge once a project was under way. Of those, 28% cited timeline changes and staying on schedule, and 19% cited getting timely and accurate communication from the pros.
Put that next to the Australian data and a pattern shows up. A lot of disputes start as a misunderstanding about what was included, what it would cost or when it would be done, and then harden because nobody talked about it early.
The common flashpoints
- Extras and variations that weren't agreed in writing before the work was done.
- A start or finish date that slipped without a call.
- A quote that didn't say what was excluded.
- Defects the customer noticed after the tradie had moved on.
- Money: deposits, progress payments and the final bill not matching what the customer expected.
Habits that keep you out of the numbers
You can't prevent every problem, but most of these flashpoints come down to paperwork and communication. That's the bit you have full control over.
- 1Quote in writing, itemised, with exclusions listed. If it's an estimate rather than a fixed quote, say so. See quote vs estimate.
- 2Agree any variation before you do it, in writing, with the price. There's a guide to handling variations and scope creep.
- 3Tell the customer the day before you arrive, and call if anything changes.
- 4Walk the customer through the finished job and ask them to check it with you.
- 5Make payment stages clear from the start. Deposits and progress payments covers the basics.
- 6If something does go wrong, respond fast and calmly. Fixing it early is almost always cheaper than fighting it later.
Paperwork that protects both sides
Clear records help the customer, and they help you if there's ever a dispute. Agentize handles some of that paperwork from your phone. It drafts itemised, GST-sorted quotes from your own rate card, so what's included is written down from day one. The Scheduler books the job and emails the customer a reminder the day before. When you've finished, the Invoicer turns the job into an invoice and chases it until it's paid. When a customer texts back, the message lands in the app with a reply drafted for you to check, and you approve everything before it goes.
Problems on trade jobs are less common than they used to be, but when they happen they're costly and slow to fix. Customers know that. The tradie who quotes clearly, communicates early and keeps good records is the one they relax around.