Every so often someone offers a tradie a shortcut: a pack of five-star reviews, a service that makes bad reviews disappear, a mate who'll write a few to get things started. It can look harmless. Under Australian law, it can be anything but.
What the ACCC found
The ACCC ran a sweep looking for fake or misleading online reviews across a range of sectors. 37 per cent of the 137 businesses it looked at had engaged in concerning conduct. Home improvement and household products and services was named among the sectors with the highest proportions of potentially fake or misleading reviews, alongside household appliances and electronics, and beauty products.
The sweep also found businesses using third-party professional reviewers and review removalists to manage their online reputation. The ACCC's warning was blunt: businesses that create fake reviews, or edit or remove genuine negative reviews, to inflate their own ratings, lower a competitor's or hide genuine negative reviews from the public, are in breach of the Australian Consumer Law.
What counts as a fake or misleading review
According to the ACCC's guidance for businesses, reviews can mislead consumers if they are:
- Written by family, employees, or people paid in some way by the business, without saying so.
- Created by someone who hasn't actually used the product or service.
- Edited or changed by someone else after being written.
A business may also mislead people if it suppresses or edits negative reviews, or removes genuine reviews because they're negative. And incentives are a trap of their own: if you offer something in return for a review, the ACCC says it must apply whether the review is good or bad, and be clearly disclosed. There's more on that in how to ask for reviews without breaking the rules.
Real cases close to the trades
These aren't hypotheticals. The ACCC has taken businesses that look a lot like trade businesses to the Federal Court.
Service Seeking: $600,000
Service Seeking runs a platform where customers get quotes for jobs like gardening, building and cleaning. Its "Fast Feedback" feature let businesses draft their own review and pick their own star rating, which was emailed to the customer. If the customer didn't respond within three days, it was published automatically. In 2020 the Federal Court ordered Service Seeking to pay $600,000 in penalties.
Aveling Homes: $380,000
Perth home builder Aveling Homes ran review websites that looked independent but weren't, and held back bad reviews to give a more favourable impression. In 2017 the Federal Court ordered penalties totalling $380,000 against the company, with a separate penalty for the manager who designed the sites.
Electrodry: $215,000
The franchisor of Electrodry Carpet Cleaning posted fake testimonials, and asked its franchisees to post them, on sites including Google, True Local and Yelp. In 2015 the Federal Court ordered it to pay $215,000 in penalties.
How big the penalties can get
Those cases are the ones that got to court. The ceiling is much higher now. According to the ACCC, the maximum penalty for each breach of the Australian Consumer Law's false or misleading representation provisions is $2,500,000 for an individual. For a company, it's the greater of $100,000,000 or three times the value of the benefit obtained; or, if the court can't work out that benefit, the greater of $100,000,000 or 30% of adjusted turnover during the breach turnover period. These maximums apply to conduct on or after 28 March 2026.
A small trade business is unlikely to face anything near the top of that range. But fines, legal costs and the public damage of a court case would be more than enough to sink most operators.
Customers are on the lookout, too
Fake reviews don't only risk a fine. They risk the trust you're trying to build. A 2021 Reviews.org survey of 1,000 Australians found 52% believe they've fallen for fake reviews, and 26% couldn't tell the difference between a fake and a real one. People are suspicious, and a run of suspiciously perfect reviews can put them off.
The ACCC lists signs people use to spot fakes: a spike in highly positive or negative reviews over a short time, similar reviewer names, generic reviews with no detail about the job, and reviews written in similar language to each other.
Safe ground for tradies
Here's what you can do with confidence:
- 1Ask real customers for honest reviews, and ask all of them, not just the ones you expect to be glowing.
- 2Reply to reviews, including the bad ones, to give your side and correct the record. See how to respond to a bad review.
- 3Report reviews you believe are fake to the platform and ask for them to be removed.
- 4If family or staff review you, make sure the connection is stated, or better still, don't ask them to.
- 5Ignore anyone selling reviews or promising to make bad ones vanish.
If you think a competitor is faking reviews or a platform isn't acting, you can report it to the ACCC. It doesn't resolve individual disputes, but it uses reports to guide its compliance and enforcement work.
Earn them the slow way
The only reviews worth having are the ones customers write because the job went well. Agentize won't write, post or manage reviews for you. What it does is keep the job running smoothly: quotes priced from your own rate card, a day-before reminder emailed to the customer, invoices chased until they're paid, and after a paid job, a referral ask drafted for you to send. That steady, honest service is what real reviews are made of.