← All articles
Reputation· 4 min read

What star rating do tradies need to win the job?

Every tradie who gets a three-star review knows the feeling. The average drops a notch and it feels like the end of the world. It isn't. But the number does matter, and it helps to know where customers actually draw the line.

68%
of US consumers will only use a business with four or more stars, up from 55% in 2025, according to BrightLocal's Local Consumer Review Survey 2026.

Four stars is the floor

BrightLocal surveyed 1,002 US adults, and 92% said they care about star ratings when choosing a business. And 68% will only use a business with four or more stars.

That bar is climbing. The same survey found 31% will only use a business with 4.5 stars or more, up from 17% the year before. A rating that looked fine a couple of years ago can now drop you off the shortlist.

Those are US figures, but the pattern will feel familiar to anyone who's searched for a sparky in the map results. You scan the stars first, and anything that looks low gets skipped before you've read a word.

You don't need a perfect five

Here's the good news. BrightLocal found just 10% of US consumers say they will only use businesses with a five-star rating. Most people expect a real business to have the odd less-than-perfect review.

Australians are a bit tougher, if one survey is anything to go by. Reviews.org surveyed 1,000 Australians in 2021, and 15% said they wouldn't purchase something or even visit a business if its average rating was lower than five stars. That's a minority, but a real one.

Why a perfect score can backfire

Research from the Spiegel research team at Northwestern University, using US online retail data, found purchase likelihood typically peaked at ratings in the 4.0 to 4.7 range, then started to fall as ratings approached 5.0. The researchers suggested shoppers see ratings at the very top as "too good to be true".

That was products in online shops, not trade services, so don't read too much into the exact range. The lesson still holds. A spotless five stars from a small number of reviews can make a careful customer wonder whether they're all from your mates. A strong rating with a few honest bumps, each one answered calmly, often reads as more believable.

What moves your rating

Your average is just maths: the more good reviews you have, the less any single bad one shifts it. A business with a handful of reviews can lose half a star overnight. One with plenty barely moves.

  1. 1Get more reviews. Volume is your buffer, and it's the one thing fully in your control.
  2. 2Ask every customer, not only the happy ones you're sure about. Steady, honest volume protects your average better than cherry-picking.
  3. 3Fix the causes of low ratings. Late arrivals, surprise costs and slow replies show up in reviews far more than workmanship does.
  4. 4Reply to the low ones. A good reply won't change the star count, but it changes how the next reader sees it.
  5. 5Never fake it. Writing your own reviews or getting friends to do it can breach the Australian Consumer Law, as the ACCC rules on fake reviews set out.

What usually drags tradies under four stars

  • A final bill that's higher than the quote, with no warning.
  • Not turning up, or turning up hours late without a call or text.
  • Being hard to reach after the job when something needs fixing.
  • Leaving a mess.
  • A customer feeling talked down to or rushed.

Most of those are communication problems. That's good news, because communication is easier to fix than a skills gap.

When a low review lands

Don't panic and don't fire back. Read it twice, check the job record, and reply once you've cooled down. Thank them, own anything that was your fault, explain briefly if something's been misunderstood, and offer to sort it out offline. There are full scripts in how to respond to a bad review.

If the review is fake or from someone who was never your customer, report it to the platform. Don't try to bury it with a flood of reviews you've arranged yourself.

Keeping the surprises out of the job

Since surprise costs and poor communication drive so many low ratings, the cheapest way to protect your stars is to be clear from the start. Agentize helps with that. Its Quoter turns a short voice note and a couple of photos into an itemised, GST-sorted quote priced only from your own rate card, and anything it can't price is left blank and flagged for you rather than guessed. The Scheduler emails the customer a reminder the day before, and when they text back, a reply is drafted for you to check and send.

It doesn't ask for or manage reviews. It just keeps the paperwork side of the job tidy, which is a big part of what customers end up rating you on.

The bottom line on stars

Aim to stay above four stars, treat 4.5 and up as the target, and stop worrying about a perfect five. Build enough reviews that one grumpy customer can't sink your average, and reply to the tough ones like the professional you are. That combination wins more jobs than a flawless score ever will.

KEEP READING

LET THE CREW DO THE ADMIN.

Agentize quotes your jobs, sends the invoices and chases the cash, in your name, from your own rates. Your first 8 quotes free. 7 days. No card.

Start free trial See how the Agentize crew works