Skip to content
Try Agentize free
Try Agentize free

Elsternwick · Melbourne, Victoria · October 2026 figures

Best Italian restaurants in Elsternwick, VIC

The top-ranked Italian restaurants in Elsternwick are Copycat Bar & Restaurant (4.6 from 426 reviews), Millers Pizza Elsternwick (4.4 from 406 reviews) and ORO Italian Dining (4.4 from 178 reviews). 5 are ranked here, in the order of the 483 on the Melbourne list.

Ranked
5
Median rating
4.4
Reviews behind the list
1,375
Open Saturday
5 of 5

The ranked list

  1. Rank 1.

    Copycat Bar & Restaurant

    Elsternwick · #121 in Melbourne

    4.6 426 reviews Proven 4.57

    Open weekendsOpen late

    0468 883 277Website
  2. Rank 2.

    Millers Pizza Elsternwick

    Elsternwick · #282 in Melbourne

    4.4 406 reviews Proven 4.38

    Open weekendsOpen late

    (03) 9523 1771Website
  3. Rank 3.

    ORO Italian Dining

    Elsternwick · #303 in Melbourne

    4.4 178 reviews Proven 4.36

    Open weekendsOpen late

    (03) 9191 9592Website
  4. Rank 4.

    Motorina Pizzeria

    Elsternwick · #427 in Melbourne

    4.1 63 reviews Proven 4.08

    Open weekendsOpen late

    (03) 9528 6044Website
  5. Rank 5.

    Etto Pasta Bar - Elsternwick

    Elsternwick · #464 in Melbourne

    3.8 302 reviews Proven 3.81

    Open 7 daysOpen late

    (03) 9528 5423Website

Italian Restaurants in Elsternwick at a glance

  • 5 Italian restaurants in Elsternwick are ranked here, with 1,375 Google reviews between them and a median rating of 4.4.
  • 100% list a website and 100% a phone number on Google.
  • 5 of the 5 that list opening hours open on Saturday, and 5 on Sunday.
  • Copycat Bar & Restaurant in Elsternwick has the most Google reviews (426), averaging 4.6.

Agentize for Italian restaurants

Your admin, done by a crew.

Agentize is an AI admin crew for Australian small businesses: quotes from your own prices, invoices in your name, and polite follow-ups on what's owed. Built for tradies, and it works for any business that bills its customers.

  • Quotes from a 30-second voice note
  • Invoices sent, late payers chased
  • Your prices, your name, nothing sent without your OK

Start free trial See how it works

200 tokens free for 7 days, no card.

Listed in Elsternwick?

Your listing here is free. It comes from your Google Business Profile, and there is nothing to sign up for to stay on it.

Questions

Who are the best Italian restaurants in Elsternwick?

The top-ranked Italian restaurants in Elsternwick are Copycat Bar & Restaurant (4.6 from 426 reviews), Millers Pizza Elsternwick (4.4 from 406 reviews) and ORO Italian Dining (4.4 from 178 reviews). Each is ranked by proven rating, its Google rating weighted by the number of reviews behind it.

How many Italian restaurants are there in Elsternwick?

The Agentize Directory ranks 5 Italian restaurants in Elsternwick, each with a Google rating from at least five reviews. Their median rating is 4.4, from 1,375 reviews in all.

Which Italian restaurants in Elsternwick are open on weekends?

5 of the 5 that list hours on Google open on both Saturday and Sunday. The highest ranked of them are Copycat Bar & Restaurant, Millers Pizza Elsternwick and ORO Italian Dining.

Which Italian restaurant in Elsternwick has the most reviews?

Copycat Bar & Restaurant has the most Google reviews of any Italian restaurant ranked in Elsternwick: 426, averaging 4.6.

How is this list of Italian restaurants ranked?

Every list is ranked by proven rating: a business's Google rating weighted by the reviews behind it, so a perfect score from five reviews cannot outrank a near-perfect one from five hundred. No business pays to be listed or to move up. How the ranking works.

Italian Restaurants in other Melbourne suburbs

All 483 Italian restaurants in Melbourne

More in Elsternwick

Ratings and review counts are Google's, as listed in October 2026. Phone numbers, websites and opening hours are the ones each business lists on Google. No business pays to be listed or to move up, and none is verified or endorsed by Agentize. How the ranking works.